Insurance Costs in 2026: The Line That Breaks Deals

By The vekstio team · · 5 minute read

For most of the last decade, insurance was a line you copied from the statement and forgot. That stopped being safe. It is now the expense most likely to be wrong on the day you close.

The short version
  • Insurance costs eased in the last year and remain far above their level five years ago.
  • The premium on the seller's statement is the seller's. Yours is priced at your purchase.
  • Get a written quote during due diligence, and test the deal with the premium 50% higher.

What happened

Between 2015 and 2024, insurance was the fastest growing cost of running an apartment building, rising close to 12% a year, according to data reported by GlobeSt. Property taxes, the usual villain, grew at less than half that pace.

The last year brought some relief. Insurance costs fell about 6.2%, yet in the first quarter of 2026 they were still 60.2% higher than five years earlier, according to Yardi Matrix figures cited by the National Multifamily Housing Council.

So the direction improved. The level did not go back.

Why the statement is wrong

The premium on a seller's T12 was negotiated for the seller: their claims history, their portfolio, their renewal date. Your policy is written new, at your price, with your lender's coverage requirements.

And lenders have opinions. Tighter insurance terms have been delaying apartment closings, because a loan cannot fund until coverage that satisfies the lender is in place.

What it does to value

How to underwrite it

  1. Start from the statement, but mark the number as unconfirmed.
  2. Check it per unit. Roughly $1,000 to $1,200 a unit a year is a common range for apartments, and more near the coast. A statement far below that deserves a question.
  3. Get a written quote early. Send an agent the address, year built, roof age, construction type and the loss history. Do this in the first week of due diligence, not the last.
  4. Test the downside. Run the deal with insurance 50% higher. If coverage on the loan fails, your price has no cushion.

Read the months

Insurance on a T12 often appears as uneven payments. A jump partway through the year is usually a renewal. That newer monthly figure, multiplied by twelve, is closer to the truth than the annual total.

Ask for the loss runs

Loss runs are the building's claims history. Three years of them tell an insurer how to price you, and they tell you what has gone wrong with the roof and the pipes.

The question to ask

To an agent: what would property and liability coverage cost for this building at this price, and what has changed at renewal in this area? To the broker: can you send the current policy and three years of loss runs?

vekstio marks insurance as a number that needs a quote and puts both questions on your call sheet. Underwrite your first deal free.

Sources

The building in the examples is invented. This guide is educational and is not investment, tax, legal or lending advice.

See it on your own deal

Drop the T12, the rent roll and the OM. Your first deal is free and complete, with nothing hidden.