Cap Rate Explained: The Three You Must Keep Apart
Cap rate is NOI divided by price. It is the return you would earn if you bought the building with no loan. That is the whole definition. The trouble starts because every deal contains three different cap rates and people use the word for all of them.
- Going in, market and exit are three different numbers.
- The cap rate printed in a listing is the seller's income over the seller's price.
- You cannot control cap rates. You can control NOI.
The three
| Name | What it is | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Going in | This building's NOI over your price | Your own rebuilt numbers |
| Market | What buyers pay today for buildings like it | Sales data and people who are not selling this deal |
| Exit | The market rate you assume on the day you sell | Your judgment, set above today's |
Small moves, large money
Take the example building with $513,050 of real NOI:
| Cap rate | Value |
|---|---|
| 6.0% | $8,550,833 |
| 6.5% | $7,893,077 |
| 7.0% | $7,329,286 |
Half a point is more than $600,000. This is why the source of your market cap rate deserves more care than almost any other input.
Recompute the one in the listing
The listing for our example says a 6.0% cap rate at $9,500,000. That math uses $570,000 of NOI: the seller's income, the seller's tax bill and no management fee.
Put your own costs in and NOI is $513,050. At $9,500,000 that is a 5.4% cap rate, not 6.0%. Nothing about the building changed. Only the honesty of the numerator.
Where to get the market number
- A submarket report for the right property class.
- Brokers and property managers who are not involved in this sale. Ask several and take the middle.
- Recent sales of similar buildings nearby, if you can see their real income.
Do not ask the listing broker. It is not that they will lie. It is that you are asking a person selling a car what cars are worth.
Buy at a gap
Your going in rate should sit above the market rate. That gap is your margin of safety. If the two are within a few hundredths of each other, you are paying full price for an asset and getting nothing for the work.
Plan for it to rise
On the day you sell, assume the market is a little worse than today. A common way is to add a tenth of a point for every year you hold, so a 6.5% market today becomes 7.0% in five years.
Some forecasts are calmer than that. CBRE's 2026 outlook expects cap rates to hold steady this year. That may well be right. But a plan that only works if cap rates fall is a bet, and you are not being paid to make it.
What you can control
You cannot move the market cap rate. You can raise NOI: better collections, market rents as leases turn, costs that were out of line. A deal where NOI can grow makes money if cap rates rise a little, more if they hold and a lot more if they fall.
vekstio keeps the three cap rates in separate cells and will not let the listing's number stand in for the market's. Your first deal is free.
Sources
The building in the examples is invented. This guide is educational and is not investment, tax, legal or lending advice.