How to Price an Offer on an Apartment Building
Most buyers take the asking price, knock off 10% and call it an offer. That number has no reason behind it, and the broker can tell. A better offer starts from the other end.
- Write down the returns you need before you look at the price.
- Solve for the highest price that still meets all of them. That is your ceiling.
- Open below the ceiling, and send the reasons with the number.
Decide what a good deal is first
Before the listing gets a vote, write your minimums. A common set looks like this:
- Loan coverage of at least 1.25 in every year.
- Cash on cash of 7% on average.
- A 15% internal rate of return to investors.
- An equity multiple of 1.8 over five years.
- No year with negative cash flow.
Yours may differ. What matters is that they exist on paper before you fall for a building.
Price what the building does today
You pay for the income that exists. Rent you will raise, utilities you will bill back and units you will renovate are your gain for doing the work. If you pay the seller for them, you did the work for free.
Rebuild the NOI
Use your taxes, your management fee and a real vacancy number. On the example building this takes NOI from the seller's $570,000 to $513,050. The posts on reading a T12 and vacancy cover how.
Find the ceiling
Now put the asking price in the model and watch the minimums fail. Lower the price until they all pass. Then raise it until one fails again. That edge is your ceiling.
Doing this by hand takes patience because several things move with the price at once: the loan, the tax bill, the closing costs and the fees. Hold any of them fixed and the answer drifts.
Open below the ceiling
Sellers counter. If you open at your maximum you have nowhere to go, and you look inflexible when you say no to the counter.
Make the number look calculated
Round numbers look like guesses. $7,349,750 looks like it came from somewhere, because it did.
Send the reasons
A low offer with no explanation is a lowball. A low offer that says taxes reset at the sale, management was missing and the lender sizes to 1.25 is business. Brokers send their next deal to the buyers who explain themselves.
One page is enough: their NOI, your NOI, the three lines that differ and what each is worth at the market cap rate.
When the price cannot move
Offer terms. A faster close, a larger deposit, proof of funds and fewer conditions are all worth money to a seller who values certainty.
And when they say no
A no to your ceiling means the deal does not work for you today. That is the system doing its job. Stay in touch with the broker. A surprising number of first choices fall through.
vekstio solves for the ceiling directly and moves the tax, the loan and the fees with every price it tests. Your first deal is free.
The building in the examples is invented. This guide is educational and is not investment, tax, legal or lending advice.