Economic vs Physical Vacancy in Apartment Underwriting

By The vekstio team · · 4 minute read

A broker tells you the building is 92% occupied. You write down 8% vacancy. You have just made the most common mistake in apartment underwriting, and it took four seconds.

The short version
  • Physical occupancy counts occupied units. Economic occupancy counts collected rent.
  • Economic vacancy is almost always worse.
  • Use 10% until a local property manager gives you a real figure.

Two ways to count

Physical occupancy is occupied units divided by total units. It comes from the rent roll, on one day.

Economic occupancy is rent collected divided by rent scheduled. It comes from a year of statements.

Why they differ

  • A unit sits empty for three weeks between tenants. Both leases existed. Nobody paid those weeks.
  • A tenant is in the unit and three months behind.
  • A new lease came with a free month.
  • A renewal was signed below the old rent to keep the tenant.

None of these show up as a vacant unit. All of them show up as missing money.

The statement with no vacancy line

Owners who keep their own books often record what came in and call it gross rent. The statement then shows no vacancy, no concessions and no bad debt.

Do not read that as a full building. Compare the top line with twelve months of the rent roll. The difference is the vacancy the statement forgot to name.

What to use

Start at 10% of scheduled rent. If the building's own history is worse, use the history. A property manager who runs similar buildings nearby can talk you down to 7% or 8% with evidence. Nobody should talk you down to 5% with a rent roll.

Be careful about tapering it. Assuming vacancy improves by a point a year is a pleasant story. Some markets sit near 10% for years, and it is the market, not the operator.

This matters more in 2026 than it did in 2022. Yardi expects about 450,000 new apartments to be delivered this year, and rent growth of only around 1.2% nationally, NAR reports. New buildings nearby compete for your tenants with free months.

Do not count it twice

If your vacancy number already comes from collected rent against scheduled rent, it includes concessions, bad debt and the discount on new leases. Adding separate allowances for those on top charges the building twice.

The question to ask

Ask a local property manager: what economic vacancy, rent collected against rent due, do buildings like this run at here? And ask the broker for the delinquency report: who owes, how much and for how long.

vekstio compares the statement with the rent roll and tells you when the vacancy is hidden. Try it on your own documents.

Sources

The building in the examples is invented. This guide is educational and is not investment, tax, legal or lending advice.

See it on your own deal

Drop the T12, the rent roll and the OM. Your first deal is free and complete, with nothing hidden.